A customer asks for a refund and is declined within seconds. Nobody in the business made that call. A rule did, set up in a payments tool two years ago by someone who has since moved on. When the customer complains, it takes three people and two days to work out why.
Most businesses have decisions like this. They were never designed as decisions; they arrived inside software, a setting at a time. That is decision debt, and like technical debt it is invisible until someone asks you to explain it.
What changes on 10 December
The Privacy and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2024 set this date in law: the automated-decision provisions start 24 months after the Act received Royal Assent, which it did on 10 December 2024 [4]. In the regulator's words, from that day organisations covered by the Australian Privacy Principles "must include information in their privacy policy where they have arranged for a computer program to make or inform decisions that significantly affect individuals' rights or interests" [1].
Three details in the OAIC's guidance stand out for anyone running operations:
- A person in the loop does not take a decision out of scope. It can apply "even where a computer program output does not replace the entire decision-making process or is subject to human review" [2].
- Bought-in software counts. The OAIC lists buying a third-party program, configuring off-the-shelf software and relying on a program's advisory output as ways a business can have arranged for software to decide [3].
- Its examples are ordinary. They include an employer letting staff use an AI chat tool to draft performance assessments that decide promotions, and a business contracting a third party to approve or decline refunds automatically [2].
Not every automated decision is covered: it has to be one that could reasonably be expected to significantly affect someone's rights or interests, and the OAIC's non-exhaustive list runs from essential banking and credit to employment and housing [2]. The Act also makes the new requirement one for which the regulator can issue infringement or compliance notices [4]. Which of your decisions fall in scope is a question for your privacy adviser. This article is about the step that has to come first.
You cannot describe what you have not found
Ask a leadership team to list the decisions its software makes about customers and staff, and the answer is usually a list of systems. That is not the same thing. A billing platform is one system; inside it may sit a dozen decisions: who gets credit, when a service pauses, which account goes to collections. Some were configured on purpose. Others came with the vendor's defaults.
That is why this lands on operations rather than legal. The OAIC's own advice is that organisations in doubt "should take a cautious approach" [3], but caution needs a starting list, and only the people who run the work can produce it. Map where software decides in your business, and the draft builds as you go.
Where does your business let software decide?
Choose the areas you run, then tick what software does there
2 · Decisions software makes or shapes there
3 · Your draft decision inventory
1 of 13 candidate decisions
Approving or declining refunds
Refunds and credit · Software can make it · Third-party refunds service
- Owner
- To fill
- Human role
- To fill
- Last reviewed
- To fill
A starting list for discussion, not a legal assessment. Whether a decision is covered by the Privacy Act depends on your circumstances, so check scope with your privacy adviser. Illustrative examples; nothing you select leaves this page.
Most businesses that do this find more than they expected, and not all of it is a privacy question. A rule nobody can explain is an operational risk even when no law applies: it fails customers quietly, resists improvement and becomes very hard to defend once someone asks.
Paying down decision debt
The fix is not a project to document everything at once. It is a handful of habits that keep the list true.
Four Moves
Paying Down Decision Debt
A list of systems will not show you where decisions happen. A rule inside a billing platform, a score in a recruitment tool or a setting someone configured years ago can all decide, or shape, an outcome for a person. Start from the work and trace each point where something is approved, declined, ranked, paused or prioritised.
First step
Take one end-to-end process, such as order to refund, and list every point where the outcome for a person could go one way or the other. Note which of those points software makes or shapes.
Beyond any one rule
Most businesses find decisions nobody intended to automate. That alone is worth knowing before a customer, an auditor or a journalist finds them first.
The rule is the occasion, not the point. Businesses that can list their decisions, name an owner for each and explain them in plain language will find the new obligation straightforward, and they will run better for it. So leave with one question: if a customer asked you tomorrow why your systems decided something about them, who would answer, and how long would it take?
This article is operational commentary, not legal advice. Check how the Privacy Act applies to your business with your privacy adviser.
Sources
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. New resources on transparency for use of AI and automated decision-making. 30 September 2026.'On 10 December 2026, APP entities must include information in their privacy policy where they have arranged for a computer program to make or inform decisions that significantly affect individuals’ rights or interests.'View source
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. APP Guidelines, Chapter 1: Australian Privacy Principle 1 — Open and transparent management of personal information (Version 2.0). September 2026.A decision may be in scope 'even where a computer program output does not replace the entire decision-making process or is subject to human review.' Examples include an employer who 'permits or directs employees to use an artificial intelligence (AI) chat tool to draft performance assessments that determine promotion decisions', and an entity that 'contracts a third-party software company to automatically approve or decline refunds on its behalf'. Significant rights or interests on a non-exhaustive list include access to essential banking and credit services, employment opportunities and housing.View source
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. APP 1.7–1.9 Transparency Obligation Fact Sheet. September 2026.Ways an entity may have 'arranged for' a computer program include 'procurement of a third-party computer program', 'configuration or customisation of existing off-the-shelf or packaged software' and 'reliance on advisory outputs from a computer program'. Entities in doubt 'should take a cautious approach'.View source
- Federal Register of Legislation. Privacy and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2024 (No. 128, 2024), as made. Assented to 10 December 2024.Commencement table: Schedule 1, Part 15 (Automated decisions and privacy policies) commences 'The day after the end of the period of 24 months beginning on the day this Act receives the Royal Assent', shown as 10 December 2026. Part 15 inserts APP 1.7 into section 13K, the 'Civil penalty provision for which infringement notices or compliance notices can be issued'.View source