All insights
peak-seasoncustomer-operationsreturnscapacity-planningconsumer-guarantees

The second peak: why promotions create work long after the sale ends

Black Friday moves spending into November, and every order it creates can come back later as a return, a fault claim or a question. That second wave tends to arrive over the summer break, when teams are thinnest. Most businesses plan for the sale. Fewer plan for what follows it.

Yasir Aheer17 November 20267 min read

A Black Friday sale is planned for weeks. Stock is ordered, the website is tested for load and extra people are rostered for the warehouse and the inbox. Then the sale ends, everyone exhales and the business turns towards Christmas.

The work does not end with the sale. Every order a promotion creates can come back: a parcel that went missing, a size that did not fit, a fault found on Christmas morning, a question about a refund. That work arrives weeks later, and for many businesses it lands in the most thinly staffed weeks of the year.

Promotions move demand, not just add to it

When retail turnover fell in December 2023, the Australian Bureau of Statistics explained why: "Consumers brought forward some of their usual December spending to November to take advantage of Black Friday sales" [1]. Retailers told the ABS that trading was slow in early December, then picked up again before Christmas and the Boxing Day sales [1].

The pattern has held since. In November 2024, six of the nine household spending categories rose, "mostly driven by Black Friday sales" [2]. In November 2025, growth in goods spending "was driven by Black Friday sales" [3].

So a promotion concentrates demand as well as adding to it: more orders, in fewer days. For operations, the concentration matters more than the total. Work that arrives in a burst gets processed in a burst, and so does everything that follows from it.

The work that comes back

Every order carries a tail. A share of them return as work: a delivery query, a change-of-mind return, a fault claim, a refund that needs chasing. Each arrives on its own timetable. An order placed on Black Friday, 27 November, might be delivered in early December, given as a gift on Christmas Day, found faulty a few days later and raised in the first week of January.

That is the second peak. It is smaller than the first, but it arrives when capacity is lowest: leave is booked, the people who know the returns process are away, and January's normal work is starting. As The Measurement Trap explains, a team running near its limit has no room to absorb a surge, and the queue grows far faster than the workload does.

After-sales work is already under pressure. Reports to the ACCC about consumer guarantees "rose by 20 per cent to over 38,000 in 2025, compared to the previous year" [6].

Nobody publishes the size of the second peak for your business, so the model below uses your assumptions. It assumes the sale weeks themselves are fully staffed, as most peak plans are, and shows what happens next.

Try your numbersWhen the work from the sale comes back

After-sales work peaks in the week of 28 Dec, at 2.1 times a normal week, during the break. Work waiting peaks at 1.5 weeks of normal work, with 0.9 weeks still waiting at the end of January.

Second peak

w/c 28 Dec

2.1× normal after-sales work, during the break

Work waiting, at worst

1.5 weeks

of normal work, queued

Back to normal

Not by February

0.9 weeks still waiting at the end of January

The second wave arrives when the team is thinnest. Work queues over the break and is still being cleared when January’s normal work starts.

Illustrative: your assumptions, not measured data. Assumes the sale weeks themselves are fully staffed.

Weekly workload, capacity and work waiting, in normal weeks of orders
Week startingOrdersReturns, claims and questionsCapacityWork waiting
2 Nov1.000.201.440.00
9 Nov1.000.201.440.00
16 Nov1.000.201.440.00
23 Nov (sale week)2.500.202.700.00
30 Nov (sale week)2.500.202.700.00
7 Dec1.000.201.440.00
14 Dec1.000.201.440.00
21 Dec (break)1.000.280.860.41
28 Dec (break)1.000.420.860.97
4 Jan (break)1.000.420.861.53
11 Jan1.000.281.441.37
18 Jan1.000.201.441.13
25 Jan1.000.201.440.89

With the starting settings, nothing goes wrong during the sale. The queue starts building in the week before Christmas and is still not cleared by the end of January. Move the break capacity to 85% and it clears in late January; shorten the delay to one week and the second peak lands before the break. The lever is not more people on Black Friday. It is knowing when the work comes back, and who will be there to do it.

Under pressure, the rules still apply

The busiest weeks are when shortcuts are most tempting. A script written carefully in October gets shortened in January; a template email says "sale items can't be returned"; a temporary team member tells a customer to contact the manufacturer. Each is a small decision made at speed, repeated across hundreds of contacts.

The consumer guarantees do not pause for peak season. The ACCC says the basic rights they cover "can’t be taken away by anything a business says or does", and gives "displaying a ‘no refunds’ sign" as an example [4]. Its guidance sets out how remedies work. For a major problem with a product, the consumer chooses between a refund and a replacement. For a minor problem, the business must fix it or repair the product for free. And businesses must not tell consumers to take the problem to the manufacturer [5]. Change of mind is different: the guarantees do not cover it, but a business that has a change-of-mind policy must follow it [5].

The regulator is paying attention. In 2025 the ACCC received over 3,000 reports about businesses telling consumers they were not entitled to a remedy, and it supports a proposal that would introduce penalties for businesses that fail to provide remedies [6]. How these rules apply to your products and policies is a question for your adviser. The operational point is simpler: the second peak is where your returns process is tested hardest, so it is the part to check before the sale.

Planning for both peaks

Four Moves

Planning for the Second Peak

Peak planning usually stops at fulfilment. Extend the plan to cover what comes back: returns, fault claims, delivery questions and refunds, with an estimate of when they arrive. Then compare it with the leave calendar before the leave is approved.

First step

Take last year’s promotion and count after-sales contacts by week through January. Put that curve next to this year’s staffing plan.

If your business slows down over summer, our guide to a summer close-down covers keeping cash, payroll and customer promises moving. The second peak is a reason to put the returns and claims inbox on that list.

Black Friday is on 27 November this year, and the sale plan probably already exists. Before it runs, ask one more question: when does the work it creates come back, and who will be there to handle it?

This article is operational commentary, not legal advice. Check how the Australian Consumer Law applies to your business with your adviser.

Sources

  1. Australian Bureau of Statistics. Retail sales fall in December following Black Friday (media release, Retail Trade, Australia, December 2023). 30 January 2024.'Consumers brought forward some of their usual December spending to November to take advantage of Black Friday sales.' Retailers told the ABS 'that trading conditions were slow in early December following the success of Black Friday before picking up again in the lead up to Christmas and Boxing Day sales'.View source
  2. Australian Bureau of Statistics. Household spending rises with Black Friday sales (media release, Monthly Household Spending Indicator, November 2024). 10 January 2025.'Six out of the nine spending categories rose in November, mostly driven by Black Friday sales.'View source
  3. Australian Bureau of Statistics. Household spending remains strong in November (media release, Monthly Household Spending Indicator, November 2025). 12 January 2026.'Growth in goods spending, which lifted 0.9 per cent, was driven by Black Friday sales.'View source
  4. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Consumer rights and guarantees. Accessed November 2026.'The basic rights covered by consumer guarantees can’t be taken away by anything a business says or does.' Examples include 'displaying a ‘no refunds’ sign'.View source
  5. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Repair, replace, refund, cancel. Accessed November 2026.For a major problem with a product, the business 'must give the consumer the choice of a: refund, or replacement'. For a minor problem, 'the business must fix the problem or repair the product for free'. 'Businesses must not tell consumers to take the problem to the manufacturer or importer.' Change of mind is not covered, but 'if a business has a ‘change of mind’ policy, they must follow it'.View source
  6. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Rising contacts raise concerns about electronics and whitegoods sector compliance with consumer guarantee rights. 24 April 2026.'Reports to the ACCC about consumer guarantees rose by 20 per cent to over 38,000 in 2025, compared to the previous year.' 'In 2025, the ACCC received over 3,000 reports about businesses who were telling consumers that they were not entitled to a remedy'. 'The proposal, supported by the ACCC, will introduce penalties for businesses which fail to comply with their obligations to provide remedies to consumers.'View source
Y
Yasir Aheer· Founder, OpsTeam

Yasir Aheer is the founder of OpsTeam. He writes about engineered operations, operating-model design, and the business and organisational implications of running People + Engineered Platforms + Production AI as one integrated system.

Ready to put this thinking into practice?

We design and operate integrated operating models for organisations ready to compound efficiency. Let's discuss yours.

Schedule Discovery Call